Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Second (sort of) Comment on Homologous Legs

Lesson for all: Don't use bare assertions to accuse someone of making them.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

"No matter how much evidence and arguments are given in contradiction to irreducible
complexity, he still claims it is?"

Making a claim without substantiating it so...

"Logical Fallacy Fail!"

QED
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_by_assertion
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bare_assertion_falla...

If you're going to claim Behe simply wrote two books based around bare assertion alone, then
at least give specific examples. Then the irony of your comment won't be as apparent.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.16 (MingW32)
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=8NfD
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments that aren't encrypted with my key and are also digitally signed with sender's own key go to the trash. I might skim them for lulz though...

This is the policy given to me by Janus. They don't agree with my views, but since they are willing to protect my real identity this is the least I can do in return.

Crypto-IDEA WA: Don't waste your time here. We have a far more cryptographically secure outpost than this one...