Scaffolding and Irreducibility - Sententias

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Thomas - could you point to any biological examples of this scaffolding evolutionary process?
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)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=/903
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Comment on Sententias Post

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

While I generally haven't considered myself to be a religious person, I will definitely be looking into this further.

You've definitely given me a lot to think about...
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)

iQGcBAEBAgAGBQJQRFHiAAoJEAlY1kTu1KLh/zwL/1bHfLLoi64Y9SanLhyzIwCM
5BbWBEi3F57XPXdNqrO8usg1rL+5JBlFRUHxcSkw3cA01T3KGCHgb0IUxxxOK3db
w6TOZZVzy2vic4UcBKezHXTSq+/ecKYsOkzbbjIYVXIj6UT9usKpJ4p0Jsqo+bJh
a3NAQExDuzB0wTuJgAtf2Ewql3dFhAbyjSbD4OLfZnDr9Yd1gkxBrq5xJzRf/bQx
yD8DnxVmKJtumPyGoY+5gPuV51sgHMy0x4XpnxGmKOCWatFmf2F2AkOrZWcck0wX
ZfumyNoL95Ta7WZO6QY0ALQECzF3+Zk5I7giMpFxRDmnSry2fRM7jitON+bwMhXU
JIFokT/TLmiVYdvCCJMjUqN8I9PtKOUmT73rnU/0UuclEIXOo96LZCWldZsUf6/W
HBXfQPl4O91KmCAOQJ0xFh/Jc33e2ptU8sg3BlA8YK+u1QcZ3jiTojKuufPoRO9F
OsS9A/lHQEQOBkFDwuWpqT2TLONKhZxI4kkjOJ+lvQ==
=6DsV
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Response to "Hrafn" on Sententias

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

1. No, it's an argument from evidence.

2. Any examples?

3. The only people changing definitions are the critics. First they rely on attacking false definitions
(Ken Miller for instance), then we call them out on it, then they accuse US of "moving the goal
posts." Happens the same way every time.

4. I know of only a few books that make a sociological analysis of Darwinian thought, but the
contents of those are irrelevant to what undirected processes are capable of doing.

5. When does this usually take place? By the same logic should people like Michael Ruse be
removed from the discussion?

6. Of course: http://www.uncommondescent.com/evolution/dont-fire-him-just-make-his-work-situation-a-living-hell/
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)
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=X7X6
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Endorsement of Sententias

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

You've put together an excellent piece there, and it looks like I might become a regular reader
here even if I might have some disagreements beyond ID itself.

I think I'll actually start recommending this site to others.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)
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=GC2d
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

"What Are the Top Ten Problems w/Darwinian Evolution"

Multiple comments in for this post.

 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

I dare you (or anyone else on any side of this discussion) to define positive evidence.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)
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=TmMJ
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Dark matter? Quantum theory?

Do we throw those out of consideration by the same standard since the former cannot be
studied directly and the latter has no tangible mechanism?
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)
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=uK9N
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

I'm definitely adding this ENV post to my collection of things to pass on to anyone who wants a
crash course on this debate.

As an addition within #4, I would add that selection also has trouble eliminating deleterious
mutations if they start off as neutral but become harmful as they accumulate. By the time the
aggregate effect of otherwise neutral mutations become negative, it's too late to eliminate them
 one by one.

This lack of foresight is a bigger problem for organisms with larger genomes, as highlighted in the
 book "Genetic Entropy."
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)
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=uWTn
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Comment on "Machine Revolution"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Interesting read, I think I saw an animation of this somewhere a while back.

That "if-then" statement seems pretty broad though. I guess assuming a particular origin of a
biological feature has less to do with understanding how it actually works than what practitioners
of "normal science" would have us believe.

Now comes the flurry of commenters who think they are original when they insist this feature may
have other functions outside the flagellum.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.17 (MingW32)
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=8ib4
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

ENV - "How Bright is the Future of Intelligent Design?"

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Well, once my contribution(s) to the movement get underway I hope both the awareness and acceptance of ID becomes more widespread in my area. To think that today is the fourth anniversary of me becoming permanently interested in this debate; boy has time flown.

And Dover? Hard to say whether that harmed the "IDM" Jones decided to rule against or if it actually made people more aware of ID in the years that followed. The Scopes trial didn't stop undirected evolution from gaining a following, so perhaps Dover really should be taken lightly as well.

While it may not have garnered much attention until long after Fred Hoyle began to formulate the roots of ID as we know it today, I think it's far from dead.

If anything it's just getting started...


By the way, this might come in handy for anyone who wants an education in a field relevant to ID but does not wish to go about getting a full degree:

http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2011/mitx-education-initiative-1219.html

Wish this option was around <i>before</i> I started college. Of course, MIT's new certification won't make you a tenured professor somewhere in the foreseeable future. But for any origins junkie on either side this could turn out to be useful.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.16 (MingW32)
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=AyzG
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----